Cape May isn’t just known for its beautiful beaches and charming Victorian architecture—it’s also home to a vibrant bar scene. Whether you’re in the mood for ocean views with your cocktail, a laid-back sports bar atmosphere, or live music under the stars, this seaside town has something for every vibe. Here’s our guide to the best bars in Cape May, including local favorites near La Mer Beachfront Resort.
Fins Bar & Grille: Seafood, Suds, and Summer Vibes
One of the top-rated bars in Cape May NJ, Fins Bar & Grille serves up more than just seafood—it’s a staple for anyone craving creative cocktails and live music. With an upbeat atmosphere and a menu that blends coastal flavors with gastropub classics, it’s a great spot for a lively evening.
Bonus: Their rotating draft list and outdoor seating make it a go-to during warmer months.
Elaine’s Cape May: Outdoor Garden & Summer Hangouts
Located just a short stroll from the beachfront, Elaine’s is a favorite among both visitors and locals. Best known for its whimsical outdoor garden bar, this venue shines in the summer with regular live music and themed nights. With a reputation for being one of the most entertaining Cape May bars with live music, Elaine’s is a must-stop on your nightlife tour.
The Cricket Club: Cocktail Culture in a Cozy Setting
Newer to the scene but quickly gaining a following, The Cricket Club brings an elevated feel to the bars Cape May lineup. Expect a curated cocktail menu, stylish interiors, and the kind of atmosphere that invites both conversation and relaxation. It’s perfect for date night or a chill evening with friends.
Lucky Bones Back Water Grille: Laid-Back Vibes and Local Flavor
A favorite among locals and visitors alike, Lucky Bones offers a welcoming, unpretentious atmosphere with reliably good food and drinks. Just minutes from the beachfront, it’s a great spot to enjoy hearty comfort fare, a cold beer, or a cocktail after a day by the water. With a casual nautical vibe and friendly service, it’s easy to see why Lucky Bones is a Cape May staple.
Taco Caballito Tequileria: Tacos, Tequila & Tunes
Love a lively crowd and a great margarita? Taco Caballito mixes coastal Mexican flavors with a buzzing bar scene. With seasonal events and weekend entertainment, it’s one of the best Cape May bars with live music to kick off your weekend.
Port Cape May: Drinks with a View
Nestled along the marina, Port offers one of the most scenic bar experiences in town. Known for their sunset views, seasonal drink menu, and occasional live music, it’s ideal for a laid-back happy hour or early evening toast. This hidden gem is quickly becoming a standout among Cape May sports bars and local watering holes.
Sip, Savor, Stay
Whether you’re looking for classic cocktails, local brews, or live entertainment, Cape May bars deliver. And after a night out, there’s no better place to return than La Mer Beachfront Resort, where ocean views and quiet luxury await. Book your stay today and make the most of your Cape May getaway.